The first thing I remember is the noise.
Five babies crying at once doesn’t sound like five babies. It sounds like a whole room full of them, and it sounded like music to me. I was lying in a hospital bed at St. Vincent’s in Hartford, Connecticut, so tired I couldn’t feel my legs, and I was smiling so hard my face hurt.
Five of them. All alive. All breathing. All yelling at the world like it owed them something.
The nurses had lined up the bassinets beside my bed. Two boys and three girls. Little pink wristbands and little blue wristbands. One of them, the smallest girl, had a full head of dark curls already. The biggest boy had his fist jammed in his mouth and was sucking on it like it was his job.
“They’re perfect,” the nurse said. Her name was Doreen. She’d been with me through all eleven hours. “Every single one, Emily. Perfect.”
“Where’s Richard?”
“Parking the car, I think. Or he went down for coffee. He’ll be right up.”
I looked at the door.
He’d been with me for most of the labor. Then the doctors decided on the C-section, and they made him wait outside, and I hadn’t seen him since. He’d missed the first cries.
I wanted him to hear them. I wanted to watch his face when he saw what we’d made.
When he finally came in, he was smiling.
That’s what I want you to know first. Richard came into that room smiling. He had a bouquet of yellow roses from the gift shop, the cellophane still crackling. His tie was loose. His hair was messed up from running his hands through it, which he always did when he was nervous.
“Em,” he said. “Em, are you okay? They said you lost a lot of blood. They wouldn’t let me—”
“I’m okay. I’m okay. Look at them, Richard. Look.”
He put the roses on the tray table.
He turned toward the bassinets.
And I watched his face change.
Not all at once. It went in stages. First confusion. His eyebrows pulled together, like he was trying to read something in bad light. Then he leaned closer to the first bassinet. Then the second. Then he stood up straight and looked at all five of them in a row.
The smile was gone.
“They’re…” he said. His voice came out strange and quiet. “They’re Black.”
I looked at him.
I honestly didn’t understand what he meant at first. I was so tired. I’d lost so much blood. I looked at my babies, at their soft brown skin and dark hair, and I’d already noticed, of course I’d noticed, but in my head it had just been another thing about them. Like the curls. Like the big one sucking his fist.
“Yes, Richard,” I said. “They’re our babies. All five of them. They’re yours.”
“No.”
“Richard.”
“No.” He took a step back from the bassinets. Like they were hot. “You’ve been unfaithful to me.”
Doreen, the nurse, went very still by the window.
“What?” I said. “What are you talking about?”
“Look at them, Emily!” He was shouting now. He’d never shouted at me in four years of marriage. “Look at them! I’m not an idiot! Who is he?”
“There’s nobody! Richard, there’s nobody. I swear to you on my life.”
“Then explain it.”
I tried. I really did. I was crying by then, and my stitches were pulling, and I could barely sit up, but I tried. I said that babies don’t always look like their parents. That families have history nobody talks about. That my grandmother used to say her people came from all over and nobody kept good records. That you couldn’t tell who a baby’s father was by looking at its skin. That there were tests. Blood tests. We could do one. Right now, today.
“Please,” I said. “Just listen to me. Just do the test.”
He wasn’t listening. I could see it. He was looking at the door. He was already gone in his head.
“My mother warned me about you,” he said.
That was the last thing he said to me in that room.
He turned around and walked out. He left the yellow roses on the tray table.
The door swung shut behind him, and five babies kept on crying, and I sat there with my hands over my mouth.
Doreen came over after a while.
She didn’t say anything at first. She just picked up the smallest girl, the one with the curls, and laid her on my chest. Then she pulled the curtain around my bed so nobody walking past could see me.
“You need to feed her,” she said quietly. “That’s what you need to do right now. Just that. Okay? Just the next thing.”
“He left,” I said.
“I know, honey.”
“He just left.”
“I know.”
She held my hand while I fed my daughter. Then she brought me the next one. And the next.
That night, after the nurses took the babies back to the nursery and then brought them back again for the two a.m. feeding, I sat in the dark with all five of them around me in their little plastic beds. The hallway light came in under the door. The heart monitor beeped somewhere down the hall.
I put my hand on each of them. One at a time.
“Whatever happens,” I whispered, “I promise you’ll never have to face this world alone. I’ll always be here for you. Always. Do you hear me? Always.”
The biggest boy got his fist out of his mouth long enough to yawn at me.
I took that as a yes.
That was March of 1995.
I was twenty-six. Richard Whitmore was twenty-nine.
I’d met him at a fundraiser in West Hartford, where I was working the coat check, of all things. I was a seamstress by trade. My mother taught me, and her mother taught her. I did alterations for a bridal shop on Farmington Avenue during the day, and coat checks and catering jobs at night for extra money. I was the kind of girl who could hem your pants while you stood there in your socks.
Richard was the kind of man who’d never had his pants hemmed by anyone but a tailor his family had used for forty years.
He came back to the coat check three times that night. The third time, he didn’t even have a coat. He just stood at the counter and asked me what I was reading. It was a paperback mystery with a broken spine. He asked if it was any good. I said the butler did it. He laughed so hard people turned around.
He was funny. People don’t believe that when I tell them now, but he was. Funny and a little shy and so polite it was almost old-fashioned. He opened doors. He stood up when I came back to a table. He called my mother “Mrs. Kowalski” until the day she told him to stop. 